Jane Fondais looking back on an iconic scene from her 2005 rom-comMonster-in-Law.

DuringThursday’s episode ofThe Drew Barrymore Show,Fonda discussed the moment she andJennifer Lopezgo back and forth slapping each other in the film, revealing that one of Lopez’s slaps left her with a cut above the eye.

When hostDrew Barrymorementioned the romantic comedy film, Fonda, 85, recalled, “The thing that comes to mind right away is we have a slapping scene. I slap her, she slaps me. … Well Jennifer — as per Jennifer — she had this enormous diamond ring. And so, when she slapped me one of the times, it cut open across my eye, my eyebrow.”

The actress then claimed, “She’s never apologized.”

In the film, Fonda played the titular character, Viola Fields, who plotted to stop her son (Michael Vartan) from marrying Charlie Cantilini (Lopez). The iconic slapping scene begins after Fields shows up on the morning of the wedding wearing a white gown of her own. It then turns into a fight between the women as they exchange blows.

Melissa Moseley/New Line/Avery Pix/Kobal/Shutterstock

Jane Fonda, Jennifer Lopez Monster-In-Law - 2004 Director: Robert Luketic New Line/Avery Pix USA Scene Still Comedy Monster In Law

At one point, Fonda’s character says: “You don’t go and slap somebody and then apologize, get some backbone.”

Lopez, 53, had a different recollection of the scene when she broke it down in a videoposted to her YouTube channelin 2019, saying she was “mortified,” adding: “I was like… so sorry.”

Watching the film on an iPad, Lopez remembered it being “one of the most fun scenes I’ve ever done.”

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

“We talked about how we were going to do this over and over again. I was so afraid to hit Jane Fonda in the face or hurt her in any way,” the singer and actress said. “She was so brazen and [said] like, ‘Just hit me, don’t worry about it.’ "

Lopez remembered saying, “I don’t want to hurt you,” and then “the next thing you know [Fonda] really went for it on one of those slaps.”

“The scene took on a life of its own,” she added. “I just remember afterward Jane had a blood blister right at the top of her eye. My nail, like, went up into her eye. … She didn’t care. She’s such a gangster bitch. I just love her.”

source: people.com