There has been heated debate within the galax on this number . Sadly , this is yet another example of conspiracy theorists showcasing their inability to accept logic as well as the comportment in the Star Wars universe of chance , anomalies , negligence , humanoid and alien error .
Engineers and Designers for Truth take it was the latter . What evidence is there that it was really Skywalker and the other rebels ?
I will tackle some of the master Engineers and Designers for Truth ( EDT ) claims and hopefully shed light source on what really happen that day .
EDT Claim : Lord Vader and Emperor Palpatine were part of an elaborate outline to blow up the Death Star in parliamentary law to beat up support for their conglomerate .
The Reality : What would Vader and the Emperor perchance gather from such an act ? After the Death Star was destroy , the economy of the Empire ’s reach , specifically their stock certificate in Sienar Fleet Systems and Kuat Drive Yards ( manufacturing company of the Imperial Navy Fleet , specifically its TIE attack aircraft and Star Destroyers ) fell drastically after stock bearer reverence that the Empire was in convulsion . The Empire ’s currentness system was also drastically hurt , to the point that the Galactic grocery nearly gate-crash as an unbalance in the note value of Imperial credits took a major turn of events for the worst . Galactic citizen were unsure of who would be launch the Galaxy , The Empire or a New Republic .
Add to the fact that the Death Star itself was inhabit by some of its top officials and finest stormtroopers , numbering in the one C of thousands . The Empire prosper on its hands , so eliminating such a large measure of Imperial functionary and stormtroopers ( despite the fact that they are n’t very honorable sharpshooter ) , not to name the original , droids , and many other troopers … ridiculous . Why would they give so much ? Lastly on the Death Star government note , this was a structure that had been the superbia of the Empire . The ultimate symbol to its tight reach over the galaxy . If they take into account it to be put down , that would certainly anguish their Galactic paradigm and more star system would well slip through their finger’s breadth .
EDT Claim : The X - Wings and Y - Wings were remotely moderate or flown by droids .
realism : There is perfectly no proof , beyond straight-out speculation , that the witnessed crafts ( seen vanish out of the ambiance of Yavin 4 ) were flown remotely . Could droids have been program to attack the Death Star in various attempt formations ? Yes . It ’s possible , although extremely unlikely . Besides , witnesses — whose interview were the major focus of the Death Star Commission Report — get images of the Rebel Attack Fleet ascend into skies of Yavin 4 just before the end of the Death Star . A tower guard ( see below ) , whose name has been relegate , find the launch , as did a bit of additional crewmen .
The EDT dismisses all such claims , stating that those witnesses were pay off off by the Empire and/or were forced to tell such stories in fear that the Empire would crush them with one swift stroke .
An EDT explanation also states that while witness find Rebel pilot within those cockpit , the Rebel fleet did disappear for a short period of time as they broke through the atmosphere of Yavin 4 . Now , they go on to say that the Empire plainly intercepted the fleet , took the pilot and their loyal droids , and replaced them with their own droids who went on to “ snipe ” the Death Star . There is no trial impression of this bechance at all . Not one shred of grounds beyond perfect speculation . Where did all of these Rebel pilots , pictured below during a briefing just a short fourth dimension before the tone-beginning , go ?
In fact , if you front at the below footage , taken from a groundbreaking documentary plastic film about the destruction of the Death Star , you ’ll find at timecode : 37 that there is in fact footage of a live cowcatcher within the cockpit of an X - fender , just before the Rebel attack fleet engaged the Death Star .
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2WBG2rJZGW8
Now , if this above image and footage does n’t satisfy doubter , I do n’t know what will . EDTs will simply say that this is in fact CG rendered footage , however if you equate the poor CG of the Death Star and Alderaan CG explosions ( See below ) , you ’ll see that these X - Wings are far superior images . And if they were done by the Empire , why is there such a everlasting difference in the item and overall quality of CG used ?
EDT Claim : This is perhaps the EDTs version of their smoke gun proof . The Death Star Explosion Footage , which they say proves that the Death Star demolition was in fact a fraud .
Below are their comparison shots , where you see two vastly unlike explosion of the Death Star :
Reality : The footage here , specifically the second apparent explosion that the EDT say is proof that a cabal exist , is clearly some after - the - fact CGI . Someone within the EDT community distinctly revisited the original footage , probable 20 years later accord to reliable expert , and enhanced it , if not completely covered it , with CG .
The same type of CG rendered plosion was use by the EDT in their come to Alderaan cabal footage , which showcased a very alike CG handling .
EDT Claim : There were legion contravene report of the number of ten - Wings and Y - Wings that attacked the Death Star , which proves that there was a confederacy .
Reality : First off , during the onrush , the medium was at an all fourth dimension eminent as far as different reports coming from dissimilar source . If you ask any Imperial tec , they will say that center witness report are often the most unreliable when it come to those witnesses remembering fine details of what a suspect was fatigue , what ethnicity they were , what long time they were , etc .
In this case , the telephone number of tenner - Wings and Y - Wings that were see fly out of Yavin 4 and those approaching the Death Star . They point to footage that was released 20 years after the original consequence that clearly show more X - Wings and Y - Wings draw end the Death Star than were seen in footage shown 20 twelvemonth sooner . The simple account for this is is that the original footage was from one slant while the newfangled footage was clearly for the opposite slant , showing how many Rebel ship there really were .
EDT Claim : The Empire conspired to blow up the Death Star so they could fund the construction of a more herculean Death Star .
realism : This have no sense . Why would they destruct a Death Star that they had scarcely employ in Holy Order to make another one ? The original destruct satellite . How much more brawny did they want to be ?
EDT Claim : Darth Vader had ties to the Rebel Alliance . His very own Word was one of their pilots and it was later learn that Princess Leia herself was his girl . This prove that Vader likely created the Rebel Alliance in ordination to back up the story that the Death Star was attack by such a terrorist organization .
world : Darth Vader had no knowledge that he had children . The members of the Old Republic , specifically General Kenobi and Jedi Master Yoda , kept that a mystery since the ending of the Clone Wars . He did n’t discover that Luke Skywalker and Princess Leia were his heirs until a couple year after the Death Star was destroy .
In Closing : These are just the few claims that EDT has made , declaring that the Empire is behind a major conspiracy . Since there is such water parting in the galaxy , I would like to comment on the two very dissimilar perspectives here , and why both of these groups are victims of the EDT and their conspiracy .
The Empire and their supporters
It is a tragedy that the memories of the man , extraterrestrial being , and droids that pop off that twenty-four hour period , numbering in the one C of thousands , have to be trampled on so some small-scale faction of soul can play this confederacy game .
The Rebel Alliance
It is with equal disgust that the store of the man and droids that gave their living for the freedom of the galaxy , as they attempted to unseat the malefic Galactic Empire , are trampled on by the EDT . Their heroical effort paved way for the destruction of the Empire and the death of Darth Vader and Emperor Palpatine .
at long last …
The human and alien psyche tries to make good sense of every action that it witnesses . It process . It depend . Then you enter the emotion that go along with being human , or foreign . That run to the search for rationalisation in what has proven to be an irrational galaxy . Human and alien error . carelessness . Chance . Anomalies .
These are what lead to those result that fateful day of the destruction of the Death Star . These are what the EDT continually ca n’t hold on as they seek to “ argue ” their way out of every explanation and test copy given to them . Look , I hated the Empire . But there was no cabal . The Rebel Alliance destroyed the Death Star during the Battle of Yavin . There has been no concrete evidence , beyond speculation and paranoia , that has proven otherwise .
About the author : Ken Miyamoto , Screenwriter , former Sony Pictures script reader / storey psychoanalyst , former Sony Studios amour
Did the Rebel Alliance really bollocks up the Death Star , or was it all contrive by Vader and the Emperor to drum up support for their war against the terrorists?originally appeared onQuora .
you’re able to conform to Quora onTwitter , Facebook , andGoogle+ .
This answer has been gently edit for grammar and uncloudedness .
QUORAStar Wars
Daily Newsletter
Get the best technical school , science , and culture news program in your inbox day by day .
News from the future , delivered to your present .
You May Also Like
