Photo: Albert L. Ortega/Getty; Jerod Harris/Getty

Audrina Patridgeis taking a trip down memory lane.
“We were invited to so many awards shows, and even asked to present a few times,” she said, adding that she and herThe Hillscostars at the time,Lauren Conradand Whitney Port, were called on to give Timberlake the coveted honor.
Patridge said that even though Conrad and Port “were beyond excited whenJustin Timberlakewon,” pointing out “they were superfans,” she added: “His wasn’t my kind of music, so I couldn’t have cared less, but I was excited for them.”
Whitney Port, Lauren Conrad.Jordan Strauss/Invision/AP/Shutterstock; Steve Granitz/WireImage

Once on stage, Patridge said the 10-time Grammy Award winner “wouldn’t even come up to us and accept the award in front of a packed house.”
She added that Conrad and Port were “devastated” and she was “annoyed at his rude, diva behavior.”
Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
In avideoof the moment,The Hillsstars announce Timberlake as the winner, and musicianTimbaland, who has produced many of the *NSYNC alum’s hits, joins him onstage. Timbaland grabs the Moonman award fromthe girls and insists on presenting it to Timberlake himself.
“I have to give you this award, homeboy. You are number one,” he said.
RELATED VIDEO:The Hills: New BeginningsCast Reveals Who They Think Is Most Likely to Hook Up with Each Other
Patridge labeled his remarks as a “personal attack” against reality stars, revealing that “Lauren’s jaw dropped. We were humiliated.”
Patridge’s memoirChoices: To the Hills and Back Againis out now.
source: people.com